Wheel comparison weighted rating scale

Thomas JackermeierThomas Jackermeier Member, Administrator
edited August 2016 in Blog

Some time ago I was looking for testers for the wheel comparison between

  • PWTS UE
  • PWGT3RS CS
  •  G27

http://www.911wheel.de/?q=node/3162  

it is now your last chance to leave a post there and apply for the test as I am selecting the testers now.

I want to make 2-3 rounds with about 20 to 30 testers and I am especially looking for testers which can make the test not only in english but other languages like Spanish, French, Dutch, Suomi, Italian, Swedish, German,  Portuguese etc.

The test was delayed a bit in order to include the V2 facelift version of the PWGT3RS (more on that later next week).

All testers have to follow a weighted rating scale and I would like to get your opinions about what is important to you.

Let me make a proposal and you can give me comments on what is missing or should be changed.

Of course we cannot find a solution which pleases everybody but I am sure that  there is a good indication where to go.

Here we go:

 

      100
Wheel     40
  Force Feedback    
    noise level  
    smoothness/feeling  
    strength  
    vibration motor functionality  
  Features    
    amount of buttons on wheel  
    amount of buttons (total)  
    ease of use  
    shifter paddles haptic feeling  
    shifter paddles precision  
    Adjustability (Tuning functions)  
    LED Display to show car telemetry data  
    wireless connection wheel to console/PC  
    cable length power supply  
    cable length USB  
    H-Pattern Shifter  
       
  Quality    
    Sensor resolution  
    Material / Surface  
    Ergonomy  
    construction / weight  
       
       
  Functionality    
    Mounting options  
    Ergonomy  
    Material / feeling of wheel rim  
    Stability  
       
       
Pedals     40
  Quality    
    Durability mechanics  
    Durability sensors  
    Sensor resolution   
    Material  
    Construction / weight  
    Ergonomy  
  Adjustability    
    Adjustability spring strength  
    Adjustability pedal angle  
    Adjustability pedal position  
    Adjustable pedal travel (throw)  
  Functionality    
    Stability  
    Anti-sliding  
    Pedal resistance  
    Mounting  
    Compatibility  
  Featues    
    Adjustable brake sensitivity  
    ABS Vibration  
       
       
       
General     20
    Combatibility PC  
    Compatibility PS3  
    Compatibility Xbox 360  
    Compatibility to different  pedals  
    Packaging  
    Manual  
    Service  
    Driver options  
    Driver Installation  
    Official upgrade options  
    Plug&Play  
    Price performance  

I am not sure to what level we really need to break down the rating so I made it for level 1 only so far. let me know if we shoul drate on level 2 or even level 3 as well.

Sign In or Register to comment.